Review

Masterbuilt 40 Digital Electric Smoker Review: Worth It? (November 2026)

Updated on · By the Steam Pig team

The Masterbuilt 40 digital electric smoker suits home cooks who want set-and-forget smoking up to 275°F without tending charcoal or propane. Its digital controls and side chip loader make it a strong first smoker, though the cabinet needs steady temperatures and a dry spot.

COMVIEE 1200 Watts Electric Smoker Heating Element, the Masterbuilt 40-inch digital electric smoker

In this review

COMVIEE 1200 Watts Electric Smoker Heating Element

Best for replacing a failed 40-inch element9.7/10

See it on Amazon
On this page (9 sections)
  1. The Masterbuilt 40 at a glance
  2. How the digital controls change a cook
  3. Wood chip loading without losing heat
  4. Cooking space and what fits inside
  5. Setting up the smoker for the first cook
  6. Care and the one part most likely to fail
  7. The real trade-offs of this smoker
  8. Alternatives worth comparing first
  9. Verdict: who should buy the Masterbuilt 40 digital electric smoker?

The Masterbuilt 40 digital electric smoker is a good buy for anyone who wants barbecue without babysitting a fire. You plug it in, set a temperature and time on the digital panel, and let the heating element and wood chips do the work up to 275°F.

Its main trade-offs are the uninsulated cabinet and the 275°F ceiling. Cold weather slows temperature recovery, and you won't get crisp skin or a hard sear from it.

Neither matters much if you mostly cook ribs, pork butt and brisket low and slow.

The Masterbuilt 40 at a glance

This review centers on the Masterbuilt 40-inch digital electric smoker as a class of model. Masterbuilt's digital electric line shares one control approach across sizes, and the 40-inch cabinet is the larger end of that family.

1

COMVIEE 1200 Watts Electric Smoker Heating Element: Best for replacing a failed 40-inch element

COMVIEE 1200 Watts Electric Smoker Heating Element, the Masterbuilt 40-inch digital electric smoker
9.7/10Our score
  • 1200W, 120V heating element
  • Fits many Masterbuilt 40-inch models
  • Stainless steel build
  • Wire assembly and gasket included

A drop-in replacement element for many Masterbuilt 40-inch digital smokers. Measure your old element first so the fit is right.

See it on Amazon

Pros

  • Stainless steel construction
  • Plug-and-play install for a quick repair
  • Replacement wire assembly and gasket in the box

Cons

  • Only fits listed models, so measure before ordering
  • Element edges can be sharp during install

That card is the replacement element rather than the smoker itself. It earns the top score here because a failed element is the one repair most owners will face on a 40-inch digital unit, and this part covers it.

The smoker's own selling points are simple: digital temperature and time controls, a patented side wood chip loader, a water bowl for moisture and four chrome-coated racks. Those four features carry most of the everyday experience.

The element behind the smoker matters too. The COMVIEE part is rated at 1200 watts and 120 volts and matches Masterbuilt part number 9907120027.

It covers models like the 20070613, 20072612, 20075615 and MB20072618, plus the Char-Broil 1000 Deluxe digital smokers, so the same part serves more than one cabinet.

Who the Masterbuilt 40 suits

Buy it if you want repeatable cooks and don't mind checking chips every couple of hours. It fits backyard cooks who would rather set a temperature than manage a coal bed.

Skip it if you want high-heat searing, live in a place with hard winters and no shelter, or plan to cook for very large crowds often. Those needs point to a different fuel or a bigger cabinet.

The middle ground is the first-time smoker owner. The digital panel takes the guesswork out of a long cook, so you can learn ribs and pork butt without learning fire management at the same time.

That learning curve is the real reason this style of smoker sells so well.

How the digital controls change a cook

The digital panel is the feature that makes this smoker beginner-friendly. You set a temperature and a time, and the element holds that target, so you don't adjust vents or feed fuel by hand.

That takes the guesswork out of a long cook. A pork butt that runs 10 hours no longer needs a watchful eye on the fire, because the controller cycles the element to keep the cabinet near your set point.

The ceiling of 275°F shapes what you cook. Ribs, brisket, pork shoulder, chicken and turkey all work inside that range.

Poultry skin stays soft rather than crisp, so finish it on a grill if crackling skin matters to you.

Digital control also makes the smoker predictable from cook to cook. Once you find a setting you like for ribs, you can return to it and expect a similar result.

Temperature swings are the thing to watch. An uninsulated cabinet reacts to wind and cold, so the readout can drift and the element cycles to catch up.

A sheltered spot and a full water bowl smooth that out.

If you're weighing fuel types more broadly, our BBQ smoker comparison covers electric, charcoal and propane side by side. For the direct matchup, see charcoal vs electric smoker and what each does better.

Wood chip loading without losing heat

The side wood chip loader lets you add smoke flavor without opening the door. You slide chips into the tray from the side, so heat, smoke and moisture stay inside the cabinet.

On a long cook, that matters. Every time you open the door to add chips, the temperature drops and the element works to recover.

The loader removes most of those interruptions.

Wood chips still burn down, so plan to reload every couple of hours on a long smoke. Soak chips first if you want a slower, smokier burn, and mix woods to build flavor.

The water bowl works alongside the chip tray. It adds moisture so meat stays juicy over a long cook, and you can fill it with juice or broth for a flavor hint.

Refill it when it runs low.

Keep the chip tray topped up before you close the door for a long stretch. A full tray at the start of a cook means fewer checks later.

The loader only helps if there are chips left to feed into the tray.

Cooking space and what fits inside

A 40-inch cabinet gives you room for family-sized cooks and the occasional gathering. Masterbuilt's vertical design stacks racks so you can smoke several items at once.

The smaller Masterbuilt 30 lists 711 square inches and four racks, which holds up to 6 chickens, 2 turkeys, 4 pork butts or 4 racks of ribs. The 40-inch cabinet scales that up, so a bigger bird or an extra rack fits more easily.

Think about your typical cook before you choose a size. A couple cooking ribs on weekends doesn't need the extra space.

A family that hosts often will use it.

The vertical layout also decides how you load the smoker. Put larger cuts on the lower racks where they are easier to reach and rotate, and use the upper racks for ribs or smaller items.

Leave a little gap between pieces so smoke can move around the food.

Our Masterbuilt 30 vs 40 electric smoker comparison breaks down the size difference in more detail.

Setting up the smoker for the first cook

Setup is mostly assembly, seasoning and a test run. Unpack the cabinet and racks, fit the legs and hardware, then run the smoker empty to burn off manufacturing residue before food goes in.

Follow the manual's seasoning steps. A short empty run at a moderate setting lets the cabinet settle and clears any factory oils.

Place the smoker on a level, dry surface with clearance around it. Electric smokers need a nearby outlet, and the cord shouldn't stretch across a walkway or sit in standing water.

Check that the chip loader, water bowl and grease tray all sit correctly before you start. A loose tray or a misaligned loader will cost you heat and flavor on the first cook.

Keep the smoker out of direct rain and wind where you can. Wind pulls heat off an uninsulated cabinet and makes the element work harder to hold temperature.

A dedicated outlet is worth planning for. The heating element draws a steady load for hours, so avoid sharing the circuit with other heavy appliances.

If you already own a 40-inch unit and the element has failed, the replacement kit brings a wire assembly and gasket so you can finish the repair in one sitting.

Care and the one part most likely to fail

Routine care keeps an electric smoker running well, and the heating element is the part to watch. Clean the racks, water bowl and grease tray after each cook so buildup doesn't affect flavor or airflow.

Wipe the interior and door seal, then let everything dry fully before closing it up. A damp cabinet between cooks invites rust and odors.

The element is the wear part. When it stops heating, the smoker won't hold temperature no matter what the panel says.

The COMVIEE 1200W element fits many Masterbuilt 40-inch digital models and comes as a kit with wire assembly and gasket.

Before ordering a replacement, measure your old element to confirm the fit. Unplug the smoker and let it cool completely first, and watch for sharp edges on the new part.

The kit also includes wire nuts, element screws and a gasket, so the small parts that get lost during a repair are covered. A stainless steel element resists wear and oxidation, which is what you want from a part that heats for hours at a time.

The real trade-offs of this smoker

The biggest trade-off is the uninsulated cabinet in cold weather. With no insulation, the smoker loses heat faster when the air is cool, so the element cycles more and temperatures recover slowly.

The 275°F ceiling is the second limit. You won't get a hard sear or crisp poultry skin from it, which is why many cooks finish chicken on a grill.

Electric smokers also depend on a power source. A long cook means a cord running to an outlet, and a power cut stops the cook until it comes back.

Finally, the 40-inch cabinet takes up more patio or deck space than a 30-inch model. Measure the spot before you buy, since the extra room for a bigger bird also means a bigger footprint.

Weigh those limits against how you cook. If your barbecue is mostly ribs and butts on weekends at home, the trade-offs rarely come up.

If you smoke through winter or want char and crisp skin, they will.

Alternatives worth comparing first

EAST OAK 30 Electric Smoker with Side Chip Loader

The EAST OAK is the pick when cold weather matters. Its double-layer steel and internal foam insulation hold heat in cool air, which is where the Masterbuilt 40 struggles.

It has 725 square inches over four racks and an 800W element, plus rear wheels and a handle for moving it around the patio. The cabinet is smaller than the 40-inch Masterbuilt, so it suits smaller gatherings better than a crowd.

Its 12-hour timer is the other difference. You set a cook time and walk away without checking the clock, which suits overnight pork butts.

The side chip loader works the same way as the Masterbuilt's, keeping the door shut while you add smoke.

Masterbuilt 30 Digital Electric Smoker

The Masterbuilt 30 shares the digital control and side chip loader approach in a smaller cabinet. Its 711 square inches and four racks handle family-sized cooks without crowding a small patio.

It also has the removable rear grease tray for cleanup. If you rarely cook for a crowd, the smaller size costs you little and saves space.

Masterbuilt propane smoker

If you want more heat than 275°F or you cook where power is unreliable, a propane model is the alternative. Our Masterbuilt propane smoker review covers that path.

Verdict: who should buy the Masterbuilt 40 digital electric smoker?

The Masterbuilt 40 digital electric smoker is worth buying for low-and-slow backyard barbecue, especially if you value set-and-forget cooking over tending a fire. The digital controls and side chip loader do most of the work, and 275°F covers ribs, brisket and pork butt well.

Pick it if you cook at home often, have a sheltered spot for the smoker and want repeatable results. Choose the EAST OAK 30 instead if you smoke through cold weather and want insulation.

Choose the Masterbuilt 30 if space is tight. And if you want high heat or no cord, look at a propane model before you buy.

Our scores weigh specs, features and how well each product fits what you're shopping for. The replacement element tops the list because a failed element is the repair most 40-inch owners will face, and this part covers many models.

Frequently asked questions

What temperature does the Masterbuilt 40 digital electric smoker reach?

The digital control panel on Masterbuilt's electric smokers tops out at 275°F. That range suits low-and-slow barbecue like ribs, pork butt and brisket, but it will not sear or crisp skin the way a grill or charcoal smoker can.

Do I need to add wood chips during a long smoke?

Yes, you will reload chips at intervals. The side chip loader lets you add them without opening the door, which keeps heat and smoke inside.

Plan to check and top up the chip tray every couple of hours on a long cook.

Can the Masterbuilt 40 electric smoker be used in cold weather?

It can run in cool weather, but an uninsulated cabinet loses heat faster when the air is cold. Expect the element to work harder and temperatures to recover more slowly.

A model with insulated walls, like the EAST OAK, holds heat better in those conditions.

What do I do if the heating element fails?

Replace it with a matching part. The COMVIEE 1200W element fits many Masterbuilt 40-inch digital models and comes with a wire assembly and gasket.

Unplug the smoker and let it cool fully before you start, and measure the old element first.